That is up to 15 years of training before they enter the profession, over 3 times as long as the nurses spend. Right now, family doctors are the single best source of information. With a higher paycheck the doctor would be happier. r/AskReddit is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions. Doctors should earn way more than celebrities. If you want to compare my salary with other jobs please do use this amount. A biochemist gets paid more because less people have the education to be a biochemist. It is their responsibility to have the knowledge of what can be treated now and what could be a greater risk and needs to be escalated to the appropriate specialist. After being tested and diagnosed, Jenet was on the hook for an ER bill of more than $1,000. We're not even close to that. Becoming a professional Forget the school loans part of it - if you are requiring one position to take several years longer to do, then you should acknowledge that they should have higher earning capacity when they're done. Nurses are paid less than GPs because their education represents a fraction of the sacrifice to earn it. They are the ones who lose their jobs, licenses, and potentially go to jail if they screw up. Because we have limited resources and doctors have a code of conduct they need to adhere to ethically, our care is segmented in ways to make sure the most in need are taken care of and we aren't sitting in hospitals catching illnesses waiting to do tests you never needed in the first place. You have to pay for all of it. As a result they order significantly more lab tests and other studies that physicians have to. A place to post an opinion you accept may be flawed, in an effort to understand other perspectives on the issue. My experience is of course very different from yours, but I can assure you that I, as most doctors, truly care about my patients. When I generate a report, my boss ultimately holds the legal repsonsibility so if anything goes wrong, it is his head on the line. If they were paid as a percentage of their overall cost reduction, it's a lot. How hard is it to teach a 5th grader basic calculation? We can certainly fix that piece, but it doesn't justify their high salary. This keeps the patient alive to 80 and they die cheaply in their sleep of old age. W.r.t GPs not treating more complex illnesses, this is because the Canadian model designates your GP as a "Gate keeper" of your care. And please don't drag the whole "they need to pay for their medical school bill" into the equation. American physicians deserve to be paid well for their work. I work in a data science field. Residents only make $50k/year. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Doctors.net.uk, a professional networking site, found that 593 (54%) of the 1,096 doctors who took part in the self-selecting survey answered yes when asked: "Should … All I can say is that you do not have the whole picture of family medicine in Canada. With the longer visit time with the doctor, the patient would be happier. 'Doctors and nurses are … Their job is really important. In order to change my mind, you would need to show me what is it that GPs provide that a RN or NP cannot which justify their 50% higher salary. ". A lot of professional leagues have a college requirement before a player is eligible to be drafted. The trick here to earn more in this profession is to get a specialization done. My aunt is an "advanced nurse practitioner" (she got there after a lot of additional studying and experience) and she mainly does diabetes monitoring and keeping up with people but she does deal with diagnosing new cases and can prescribe, however she double checks a lot of her prescriptions with the doctors because they are more qualified. Also, the 3rd party reimbursement have become ridiculously low. I don't know how NPs work in your province but in Quebec they litterally cannot take the hard cases, as they have strict criteria for the patients they can take under their care. Teachers definitely need to make more. Similar to what u said - there is definitely some legal/accountability context that we have to consider, but does it thereby jutsify the salary? The court quoted media reports from Hyderabad and Delhi on doctors not being paid and said "such incidents should not have happened". People tend to make what the market values them at. 2-4 years compared to 8-10 years. They have a lot more to lose. Then they die at 75. The burden of selecting which specialist's to see if purposefully taken away from the patiejt because they are ignorant to what they need and if they go to specialist who wouldn't be able to help their presenting issue, the practitioner may run tests which may cause frivolous exploration of tangential or unrelated problems because that doctor has a legal liability to explore any potential cases for harm they may determine. Say a family doctor sees a 60 year old patient, diagnoses them with a heart condition, convinces them to quit smoking, exercise more, and eat less. When things get tough, they make referrals to specialists. In Canada (and presumably USA), the average family doctor salary is between $200,000 to $250,000. How hard is it to convince people that a murderer is innocent? But we aren't there yet. And your idea that doctors don't take on hard cases is purely anecdotal. I'm not seeing why GPs should be paid a lot more. I mean, Doctors SAVE LIVES, While famous people are just performing. “Doctors earned more last year than ever before. It used to be that they take care of sick people, but now most family doctors simply diagnose, and then leave the treatment to the nurses. Source: OCDE and El Pais. The family doctor increased your take home profit by $100,000 on that one patient alone. To draw a parallel to engineering, engineers make significantly more than draft technicians. Emergency room doctors and nurses who are putting their personal health at risk to treat coronavirus patients are now finding their pay, compensation and other benefits being cut as … Why? I think personally think nurses do deserve more pay as they also have to study and work long hours on their feet. if they went to school as long as doctors and lawyers yes, but they also get paid better in some countries, Doctors keep us alive now but teachers keep us alive tomorrow. It takes 50% longer to become a GP - should their salary not reflect that effort and knowledge requirement? And they need supervision. share. That is the gross amount. Doctors get paid more because there are less of them and they are more educated than nurses. They also spent a lot of time with cadavers which doesn't sound too nice. First of all, I am sorry if you've had bad experiences with family doctors. Every year there are more tests available for doctors to order. No one working,whose salary is taxpayer funded, is going to make a lot of money. Some are excellent, and should be encouraged to get MDs. Now say the family doctor doesn't diagnose the patient. Even though machine learning is getting good results for some procedures (like skin cancer follow-up for instance), we are very far from computers replacing doctors. This will increase demand for private schools which will create more of them which will create more private schools jobs which will mean more teachers are making more money. All comments that earned deltas (from OP or other users) are listed here, in r/DeltaLog. Nurse Practitioners (NPs) instead are the ones taking on the hard cases. At the maximum, they function at the level of PGY2 residents, meaning they need to report to the attending doctors to double check their diagnoses and treatments`. In the US, it's a bit lower than that, around $189,000. The doctors don’t like it, and neither do the patients. As part of that same claim, Obama also said teacher pay … A trash collector works harder than a biochemist. Yes, because we gotta educate the future generations into not being selfish pigs willing to jeopardise humans as a species and the Earth we inhabit for some oil. There is a wide range of NP quality. It would be a win-win. It is not what I end up in my pockets with, however, as I have many expenses that are required for me to do my job. Brilliant college kids rarely become public school teachers in America. And please don't drag the whole "they need to pay for their medical school bill" into the equation. They then have a $100,000 heart surgery and hospitalization. When teachers need a decade of schooling then yes. Now, if the doctor got paid more per visit, he or she could see less patients in a day, see each patient for a longer period of time, and likely make better, holistic choices for the patient.